TRANSFER NEWS LIVE: MAN UTD MAY HAVE TO RETAIN UNDER-FIRE ONANA AMID LIMITED OPTIONS
Amorim Faces Tough Call on Underperforming Keeper Amid Limited Market Alternatives
Manchester United may have no choice but to retain Andre Onana for the 2024/25 season, with new manager Ruben Amorim discovering a lack of viable replacements in what's proving to be a thin goalkeeper market.
The £47m signing from Inter Milan endured a disastrous debut campaign, committing high-profile errors that cost United crucial points in both the Premier League and Champions League. Yet with elite alternatives either unavailable or unattainable, the Red Devils could be forced into giving the Cameroonian another chance.
Why Onana Might Stay
1. The Goalkeeper Market Crisis
Diogo Costa (Porto): €75m release clause too steep
Mike Maignan (Milan): Chelsea leading chase, priced at £60m+
Giorgi Mamardashvili (Valencia): Now Barcelona-bound
Aaron Ramsdale: Arsenal want £30m for backup keeper
2. Financial Fair Play Constraints
United must prioritize striker & center-back signings first
Can't afford another £40m+ keeper after Onana investment
Altay Bayındır remains untested as backup
3. Amorim's Pragmatic Approach
Known for improving existing players (see: Marcus Edwards at Sporting)
May back Onana to adapt after full preseason
System change to back-three could reduce pressure on keeper
The Case Against Onana
❌ Worst save percentage (67%) among PL starters
❌ Cost United 6+ points with direct errors
❌ Confidence visibly shattered in big games
Possible Compromises
🔹 Short-term competition: Sign experienced but cheap No. 2
🔹 Loan market gamble: Explore temporary deals (e.g., Kepa)
🔹 Last-chance preseason: Make final decision in August
Fan Reaction
🔴 "We'll never win trophies with him flapping at crosses" – Stretford End regular
🔴 "Amorim must be given funds to fix this" – Podcast host
What’s Next?
Amorim to assess Onana in July training
Scouts monitoring secondary targets
Saudi interest could yet materialize
0 Comments